Are SAFE Investments Really Safe?
Originally created for accredited investors in 2013, the simple agreement for future equity, or “SAFE,” has become a popular crowdfunding tool for attracting all investor-types. With a SAFE, the company takes in capital investment with the promise that it will return equity to investors upon a significant event, such as a buy-out, merger or preferred stock offering. The SAFE seems ideal for crowdfunding because the company’s lack of a then-current legal obligation to SAFE investors reduces the paperwork and maneuvering necessary to keep the founders in control of their business.
But is the SAFE really a safe investment? If you equate that to mean a guaranteed return, then no, the SAFE is certainly not safe. In fact, the SEC issued its own alert[1] to warn investors of the pitfalls in using a SAFE investment. After all, the SAFE is an investment, and all investments come with risk. In this article, I’ll explain how the SAFE differs from traditional investments and outline some issues for you to keep in mind when considering your own SAFE investment.
The SAFE is its own unique investment vehicle.
A good place to start understanding the SAFE is to realize what it isn’t. People tend to lump investments into one of two categories: debt and equity. The SAFE is neither.
When you invest your money with a SAFE, you’re not giving the company a loan and the company isn’t handing you a note. In fact, the company has no legal obligation to pay you if the future events that trigger your return never happen. And, unlike a loan, your SAFE investment doesn’t accrue any interest no matter how long you wait for those future events.
A SAFE investment also won’t grant you any stake in the company. At the time of your investment, the company hands you a promise for future equity if the company realizes a certain event. If that event never happens, you don’t get equity. Your SAFE also doesn’t get you voting rights or other similar perks that typically come along with an equity investment. When investing with a SAFE, you literally hand over your money to the founders and, well, you wait. So, don’t expect your SAFE to provide returns like a traditional debt or equity investment.
To be fair, your SAFE investment can become equity at some point, but you definitely do not have any stake in the company at the time you make your investment. If – and only if – the company triggers a defined future event, then – and only then – will your investment convert to a stake in the company.
What to watch out for when considering a SAFE.
First and foremost, you must understand the future events that will trigger your return As I mentioned previously, typical SAFE triggers include a buy-out, merger, and preferred stock offering, and other events that generally involve a significant influx of outside capital. But don’t assume the SAFE you’re considering covers every scenario in which the company is doing well. For example, if the company is earning income by selling its products or services, then your SAFE return may not be triggered even though the company is making money. Remember, your stake only vests when those triggers defined in the SAFE actually occur, not necessarily when the company becomes successful.
There are other issues to spot when reviewing a SAFE, especially in the crowdfunding realm. Consider the impact of the number of investors likely to join you in a SAFE investment crowdfunding offering. In that scenario, the company will likely not want to negotiate with hundreds of investors to later modify the SAFE terms. After all, startups change considerably over short periods of time and SAFEs have no expiration. Check to see if the SAFE designates one investor or subset of investors with the power to amend the SAFE for all of the investors. The SAFE may identify this lead investor or investor group by its investment amount, thus creating majority and minority investors within the SAFE.
You should also be aware of repurchase rights. Your SAFE may provide the company with the option to pay you for your investment even after a triggering event. In that case, understand how the company values your investment. Be wary of the company undervaluing your investment by using either its own method or through an appraiser of its choosing. Also, review any future limitation on your potential equity stake, such as reduced voting rights. All equity isn’t necessarily created equal.
The SAFE can be a viable investment option that helps startups succeed and genuinely rewards investors when the company is successful. It could fit your budget and goals, and allow you to participate in a company you believe in. Just make sure to read, understand and scrutinize the terms of the SAFE you’re considering, and ask a professional for help before making a significant investment that may not align with your expectations.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/oiea/investor-alerts-and-bulletins/ib_safes